Skip to main content
General ContractingNovember 3, 2026|Hero365 Team|6 min read

CIS for Subcontractors: Job Costing and Deductions Without a Spreadsheet

Most job costing software for construction is American and has never heard of CIS. Here's how a 20% deduction should really appear on a UK job, with a worked £5,000 example.

Picture this: it’s the 18th of the month, you’re on a first-fix in a loft, and you suddenly remember the CIS return is due tomorrow. Half your payment statements are in a WhatsApp thread. The rest are in a spreadsheet you last touched in March.

Sound familiar?

Search for job costing software for construction and you’ll get a wall of American vendor pages and “best of 2026” listicles. We checked the top results. None of the ones we looked at mention CIS. Not once. So this post is the UK version: how a Construction Industry Scheme deduction should appear on a job, what changed in April 2026, and what you should actually pay to keep track of it all.

Job costing software for construction: the CIS problem nobody mentions

Here’s the thing the US pages never explain. A CIS deduction isn’t a cost. It’s your money, held by HMRC.

When a contractor withholds 20% from your labour, you still earned that income. It’s a tax credit you’ll claim back through Self Assessment. The CIS rates are unchanged: 20% for registered subcontractors, 30% for unregistered, 0% with gross payment status.

Record the deduction as a cost and every job looks 20% less profitable than it is. So you pad quotes for the wrong reason, or you underprice because the numbers confuse you. Neither ends well.

The right job-cost view shows gross revenue, your real costs, and the deduction as a tax credit receivable. That’s it.

A £5,000 job, worked through

Say you’re a subcontractor on a loft conversion. You invoice £5,000 (ex VAT). £2,000 of that is materials you bought. £3,000 is labour.

CIS applies to labour only. The formula is (payment excluding VAT − qualifying materials you bought) × rate. VAT is never subject to CIS.

  • Split invoice: (£5,000 − £2,000) × 20% = £600 withheld. You receive £4,400.
  • Lump-sum invoice: the contractor deducts on the lot. £5,000 × 20% = £1,000 withheld. You receive £4,000.

Same job. £400 of your cash stranded with HMRC until Self Assessment, just because the invoice didn’t show the split.

Now the per-job view. Let’s say your own crew and labour cost you £1,400 (illustrative figure):

Line Amount
Revenue (gross) £5,000
Materials −£2,000
Labour cost −£1,400
Job profit £1,600
CIS deducted (tax credit receivable, not a cost) £600
Cash received £4,400

Profit is £1,600 whether the deduction is £600 or £1,000. Only the cash timing changes. A spreadsheet can do this, sure. But only if you remember to build it that way, every single job.

The dates that bite: the 19th and the 14-day statement

Say the contractor pays you on 12 June. That lands in the tax month running 6 June to 5 July. Deductions are calculated per payment within that month.

Two things are then due by 19 July:

  1. The monthly return to HMRC.
  2. Your written payment and deduction statement, which the contractor must give you within 14 days of the tax month ending.

Miss the return by a day and you’re hit with an automatic £100 penalty. It climbs to £200 after two months, then the greater of £300 or 5% of the liability at six months.

And since 6 April 2026, quiet months count too. Contractors must now file a nil return or notify HMRC of inactivity in advance for any month with no subcontractor payments. Nil returns were scrapped in 2015, so plenty of occasional CIS users have never done one.

Keep those statements, too. Most subcontractors overpay during the year and get a refund. Missing statements mean missing refund money. Reconcile each one against your own job records before Self Assessment.

What the April 2026 fraud rules mean if you pay labour

If you’re a contractor with crews or labour-only subs, the bigger change is enforcement. From 6 April 2026, if you make or receive a payment you knew or should have known was connected to fraud, HMRC can cancel your gross payment status immediately, for five years. It can also issue a tax determination and a penalty of up to 30%.

It’s not aimed at honest mistakes. But HMRC expects documented due diligence: verification before the first payment, periodic re-checks, Companies House details.

A spreadsheet can’t give you a dated audit trail you’d trust in front of HMRC. Whatever you use should store, per subcontractor, the verification date, the rate it returned and your re-check history. The rules for verifying subcontractors and what subcontractors must do are on gov.uk.

If you hold gross payment status, guard it like cash-flow insurance. The turnover test is £30,000 for a sole trader or £100,000 for a company, measured net of materials. Invoice £80k with £35k of materials and your test figure is £45k.

What job costing software for construction should cost in the UK

Here’s where the US pages fall over on price as well. Knowify starts at $99/month, and one comparison lists $329/month on an annual plan for 10 users. None of those pages mention CIS.

For a 1–15 person trade firm, that’s overkill. Here’s what UK options actually cost, using published figures:

Option Published price Handles CIS deductions?
Xero £16–£65/month, plus £5/month to file CIS300 direct ✅
QuickBooks From £16/month, Plus £56 ✅
Sage CIS v2 module £11/month + VAT, on top of Sage 50 ✅
US job-costing suites $99–$329/month ❌
Hero AI £19.99/month (AI Concierge) ❌ — it works alongside your accounts

We’ll be straight about that last row. Hero AI doesn’t file your CIS300. Your accounts package or accountant does that, and you should check the one you pick files direct and stores verification records.

What Hero AI does is the front-of-house work that makes the CIS side easy. It drafts estimates with labour and materials split out from the start, so contractors have no excuse to deduct on the lump sum. It chases the overdue invoices you’ve been too busy to ring about. And it keeps your job records tidy, so the numbers are ready when the 19th comes round. For more on the quoting side, see our guide to building estimating software.

One more reason to set up per-job categories now: Making Tax Digital for Income Tax began on 6 April 2026 for sole traders with qualifying income above £50,000. It drops to £30,000 in April 2027 and £20,000 in April 2028. Clean job data now means no scramble later.

A simple no-spreadsheet routine

  • Quote: labour and materials on separate lines. Every time.
  • Invoice: same split, so the deduction lands on labour only. Our piece on getting paid faster covers the chasing side.
  • Record: gross revenue per job, deduction as a receivable.
  • Diary: one recurring entry for the 19th covering the return and the 14-day statements, nil months included.
  • Reconcile: match statements to jobs before Self Assessment.

Running several jobs at once? Add a job-level tracker then, and not before. We’ve written about what job management software really costs if you want the full picture.

If you run a general contracting business and want Hero AI handling the calls, quotes and invoice chasing while you’re on site, download the Hero365 app. It’s £19.99/month to start — no demo call, no per-seat pricing.

Share:XLinkedIn

Related Articles

Ready to try Hero365?

The AI staff for home-services businesses

No per-user fees · Cancel anytime

Job Costing Software for Construction: CIS Guide 2026 | Hero365